THEIVES LIKE US, OR ... WHEN EISENSTEIN INVENTED MONTAGE, HE
PROBABLY WASN’T SEARCHING FOR A WAY TO SELL SOFT DRINKS.
Amanda Steggell
I was invited to take part in Norsk Kritikerlag's autumn seminar which dealt mainly with promotional music videos as a subject of study that combines aesthetic and commercial concerns. As panelists we were asked to answer two questions:
1. What are the influences
of commercial culture (in the context of music videos and advertisements) on
contemporary aesthetics?
2. Does commercial culture get the critical attention it deserves?
Here is a transcript of my contribution.
When Marit sent me an email inviting me to this panel, the first thing I did
was to call her and ask, "why me". I am not an expert on music videos,
neither have I ever produced anything of any significant commercial value. She
asked me to talk through artist glasses. The second thing I did was to do a
quick search for the roots of the music video in Wikipedia, the “copyleft”
Encyclopedia of the WWW. Here is a quick historical rundown of things that grabbed
my attention
1) 1911: At a time of rapid development in the arts and science, Alexander Scriabin,
a self-acclaimed synaesthestes, writes Prometheus - Poem of Fire, for
orchestra and light organ, an instrument that simultaneously produces music
and light at the touch of a key. The synchronicity of sound and vision could
justify the light organ as an early forerunner of the music video.
2) 1920's: The abstract animated films of Oskar Fischinger are described as
"visual music" and synchronised to musical scores, but he is critisised
by the high-arters for using light classical music. For Fischinger music is
a "means" for creating dynamic, kinetic audiovisual works, and not
the “end”. He also makes commercials to earn money.
3) 1938: The film Alexander Nevsky, directed by Sergei Eisenstein is
released. The dramatic methods of mixing audio and visual and the extended battle
scenes choreographed through numerous shots to a score by Sergei Prokoviev provide
a prime connection to the music video of more modern times. However, the film
was definitely not made to sell music or promote a band, but to warn the Soviet
people of German aggression. By a trick of the tail Alexander Nevsky was released
just before Stalin agreed to the Molotov-Ribbentrop pact creating a Soviet-Nazi
alliance, and was consequently suppressed until 1941. After the German attack
on Russia, the "message" is desirable once again, and Stalin orders
the film to be shown in every Soviet cinema. Whatever the content or intention
may be, contextual framing affects perception and interpretation.
But what most endures about his work is his editing techniques, which he identifies
as metric, rhythmic, tonal and overtonal, described as "Methods of Montage".
Through his experiments in montage and its relationship to biomechanics, he
finds that film cut metrically to the beat of a typical heart has a profound
impact on us precisely because it mirrors our biorhythms.
4) 1940: The Panorama Soundie Jukebox hits the clubs and bars in USA - a new
social context for the audio-visual spectacle. Put your money in the slot and
you get music accompanied by one-song film clips. The visual imagery is mainly
of the performing artists themselves, with the occasional flame-thrower or two
thrown in to spice things up a bit.
5) 1962-5: The short but sweet golden age of the Scopitone. A cross between
a jukebox and a 26-inch color TV, the Scopitone was the result of French technology
developed for use during WWII, turned (by CAMECA) to civilian use, projecting
3-minute song films with a high hunk-chick ratio that is apparently spectacular
enough to compensate for extremely bad lip syncing. Bikini babes lounge around
pools, bunny girls hop around fake lawns and lingerie-clad beauties are voyeuristically
glimpsed through keyholes.
6) 1975: The music video Bohemian Rhapsody, mediates the presence of Queen who
are unable to perform on the British TV chart show, Top of the Pops. Though
not Queen's first promotional video, it is the first to be shot entirely on
videotape and contains much of the visual language of latter day promotional
music videos.
7) 1977: Warner Amex Cable launches the first two-way interactive cable TV system,
QUBE, in Columbus, Ohio, offering many specialized channels, including Sight
On Sound, a music channel that features concert footage and music oriented TV
programs. With the interactive QUBE service, viewers could vote for their favorite
songs and artists. Audience participation is a good way of conducting market
research.
8) 1981: Sight on Sound switches name to MTV. First launched in New York, the
channel is modeled on the Top 40 radio show and referred to as "visual
radio", replacing sound with the music video format, and unseen radio show
hosts with visually appealing boy/girl-next-door hosts. The term VJ (which today
generally refers to the live processing and manipulation of audio-visual signals)
is coined.
MTV is available nationally by the mid 80’s, spreading quickly to Europe
and eventually a worldwide audience. Music videos are a vehicle to promote hot,
new acts and revive old rock stars. The first videos have small budgets, and
almost any band that has a video, or has live footage gets airtime for "free".
New wave, punk and heavy metal, ignored by many radio stations, get airtime
on MTV, satisfying the hunger of the 80's teens, who shun the "Woodstock"
and disco music of the 70's. Young visual artists and filmmakers with a talent
for short-attention-span storytelling language of quick editing and flashy imagery
are recruited. The power of the visual language is so effective that one short
promotional device affords instant access to a near-global market. By 1983 every
major record label maintains its own video department, and top video directors
- those skilled at manipulating viewer emotion with rapid-fire imagery - are
courted by Hollywood studios, who want to lure the MTV generation to the theatres.
Criticised for being racist due to the predominant whiteness of the featured
artists, MTV embraces the threat and responds by selling it back to the public
by heavily featuring videos from black artists such as Michael Jackson (who
has ironically grown whiter and whiter over the years). He also clinches million-dollar
deals to promote Pepsi. So does Live Aid and so does Madonna, in her own special
way.
Through the lens of the video maker, artists can re-invent themselves - again,
and again and again. The heavy rotation of music videos on the "right channels"
has the power to transform unknown bands into million-selling bands. Million
selling artists can get millions for advertising million-selling soft drinks.
This concludes my quick-and-dirty journey of link-chasing in Wikipedia.
The Wikipedia section on music videos fails to mention the influences of experimental
video artists of the 60’s who "misused" technology to create
something else by literally and figuratively cross wiring connections. For example,
by feeding back TV signals into the machine sound and image were simultaneously
generated. By using magnets to disturb signals, the audiovisual output could
be modulated creating dynamic waveforms. Such avant garde work has greatly influenced
the way video is treated through digital filters today but has received relatively
little recognition. Hopefully, this omission will be rectified in the future.
The past is editable in a current total of 85 languages in the Wiki world.
The evolution of the music video is connected to the development of technology
in terms of aesthetics, production and distribution, just as it is to the ideas
and techniques of innovative people with extraordinary talents – both
past and present. Everything is interconnected. While technology may be considered
as neutral, the context in which it is developed and used is not. Anything that
can be digitised is also infinitely digitally editable, recyclable and distributable
by anyone with access to the right tools.
By sampling and remixing media of the past and present, it is possible to challenge
and talk back to the image of the world fed through the mixed medias, merged
mediums and accumulative aesthetics that make up our environment today, while
running the risk of being reframed and fed back into the very system which is
being commented upon - as something else.
The current misbalance of power between the Davids and Goliaths of this world
can cause legal problems relating to intellectual property and copyright issues.
In the words of Grethe Melby*, today artists need to be lawyers too. Paraphrasing
artist Vikki Bennet of the Canadian duo People Like Us, and her approach to
the Avant garde – eventually, you either join the rest of the army, or
get shot.
Strategies for counteracting the misbalance of power in commodified culture
can be found in non-profit movements such as the Creative Commons. Their goal
is to update increasingly restrictive, default rules to cope with the implications
of digital and tele-communications technologies of today. They offer a flexible
copyright for creative works, allowing people to share and distribute their
work with the works of others, while giving credit where it is due.
If, in the question of this debate, "commercial culture" refers to
promotional music videos, I would say that they are worthy of serious critique,
but only when put in another context, such as curated programs in film festivals,
exhibitions and special collections, or as part of a trend study. There are
some exceptions, but looking at the myriads of formula-based, stereotyped music
videos today aimed mainly at teenyboppers with cash to spare, it is debatable
as to whether music videos will continue to have the sales potential they had
in the past. I think they will get the attention they deserve.
* Grethe Melby is a graduate student in the Department of Media Studies,
University of Bergen, Norway, writing her thesis on metaphors used to describe
new technology and their relation to political decisions.
Norsk Kritikerlag
http://www.kritikerlaget.no/
Wikipedia
http://www.wikipedia.org
People Like Us
http://www.peoplelikeus.org/
Creative Commons
http://creativecommons.org/